A segunda actividade pretende caracterizar diferentes modelos de desenvolvimento/avaliação da qualidade de cursos online, com a finalidade de apresentar um modelo de avaliação. Fruto dessa análise e da discussão gerada.
Pretendeu-se desenvolver estas competências:
• Caracterizar diferentes propostas de desenvolvimento/avaliação da qualidade de cursos online;
• Propor e fundamentar um modelo de avaliação de cursos online.
Dividida a turma em grupos, os trabalhos foram apresentados, seguindo-se uma discussão geral na turma para identificar pontos convergentes e divergentes apresentados no conjunto dos textos. Por fim, foi proposto um modelo pela turma.
O nosso trabalho - Rosalina, Pedro, Luís e eu - sobre caracterìsticas de cursos online que, entendidas como ideais, ou como modelos a seguir, focam aspectos tão diversos como o guia de curso, interactividade entre alunos, com o professor e com os conteúdos, actividades, recursos, comunicação, bases teóricas e também questões práticas destes cursos.
Algumas conclusões pertinentes do grupo:
Um curso online é um curso baseado essencialmente na Internet, tirando o máximo partido das oportunidades oferecidas pela web. A educação à distância parece ser uma importante resposta para as necessidades do desenvolvimento profissional das diversas populações e para a aprendizagem ao longo da vida. Os cursos devem ir ao encontro dos alunos, tirando o melhor partido da sua disponibilidade de tempo, energias e focos de interesses e necessidades. Estamos a caminhar para um paradigma que podemos designar de «aprender sem distância», procurando estar no lugar certo, à hora certa. Nos cursos online, tem-se dado primazia à teoria constructivista. Hoje em dia, pelo conectivismo (G. Siemens), a aprendizagem é potenciada pelas conexões que se estabelecem, com os diversos factores da aprendizagem (aluno, professor, c Uma aprendizagem online eficaz, segundo Alley (2000), centra-se totalmente no desenho do projecto pedagógico, assumindo que o conhecimento é construído, sendo a aprendizagem mais eficaz se for o aluno a assumir a responsabilidade pela sua própria aprendizagem.
Oito aspectos que devem presidir à concepção e desenvolvimento do curso:
1. Comunicação e colaboração assíncrona (discussões em grupo);
2. Número limitado de inscrições (grupos de 20 a 25 no máximo;
3. Especialista em facilitar/motivar a colaboração e a discussão online (tutor, professor, formador);
4. Confiança entre os participantes (que deverão revelar comportamentos de honestidade e espírito de inter-ajuda);
5. Calendarização das actividades (calendarização de actividades com periodicidade semanal e preferencialmente seguir a mesma sequência);
6. Excelentes materiais e variados recursos pedagógicos que deverão abordar diferentes estilos de aprendizagem (encorajar os alunos/formandos a efectuarem pesquisas, trabalhos criativos e auto-reflexões);
7. Uma boa pedagogia conseguida através da definição dos objectivos relacionados com a actividade, avaliação contínua, assuntos adequados para discussão em grupo e estratégias de aprendizagem eficazes;
8. Garantia de qualidade - os cursos deverão ser revistos, monitorizados e avaliados relativamente ao design instrucional, concepção, distribuição e impacto). Anualmente deverá ser efectuada uma verificação dos cursos.
Para este tema, foram utilizados os seguintes recursos:
ACHTEMEIER, Sue D.; MORRIS, Libby, V.; FINNEGAN, Catherine L. (2003) "Considerations for Developing Evaluations of Online Courses". JALN 7, Issue 1.
http://www.edtechpolicy.org/ArchivedWebsites/Articles/ConsiderationsDevelopingEvaluations.pdfVolume
CARR-CHELLMAN, Allison & DUCHASTEL, Philip (2000) "The ideal online course". British Journal of Educational Technology, Vol 31, Nº3 (229-241).
http://www.personal.psu.edu/users/k/h/khk122/woty/F2FHybridOnline/Carr-Chellaman%202000.pdf
HERRINGTON, Anthony; HERRINGTON, Jan; OLIVER, Ron; STONEY, Sue & WILLIS, Jackie (2001) "Quality Guidelines for online Courses:The Development of an Instrument to Audit Online Units" In G. Kennedy, M. Keppell, C. McNaught & T. Petrovic (Eds.) Meeting at the crossroads: Proceedings of ASCILITE 2001 (pp 263-270).
TINKER, Robert (2001) "E-learning Quality: The Concord Model for Learning from a Distance"NASSP Bulletin, Vol. 85, No. 628, 36-46
HOLSAPPLE, Clyde. W. & LEE-POST Anita (2006) "Defining, Assessing, and promoting E-learning Sucess: An information systems perspective". Decision Sciences Journal of Innovative Education, Vol.4 Nº1 (pp 67-85)
sábado, 14 de novembro de 2009
segunda-feira, 9 de novembro de 2009
Annoted Bibliography
About self-paced learning, this is an article on alternative learning methods.
It can be read here.
It starts presenting self- paced learning and presenting also several exemples of sel-paced learning, giving also a brief aproach on avantages and limitations on this alternative learning method. Interesting for beginners, since is easy to read.
Another interesting article on self-paced learning from Jason F. Rhode, intitled "Interaction Equivalency in Self-Paced Online Learning Environments: An Exploration of Learner Preferences" from the International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning,Volume 10, Number 1,February – 2009.
Abstract:This study demonstrated that depending on the specific circumstance, not all forms of interaction may be either equally valued by learners or effective. Participants differentiated among the various learning interactions available and indicated that informal interactions were as important as formal interactions in determining the quality of the online learning experience. Participants also reported the activity of blogging as being equally valued and in some ways superior to instructor-directed asynchronous discussion via the discussion board in a learning management system.
An importante book from Terry Anderson is "Theory and Practice of Online Learning"
You can check a glimpse of the book here.
This is a revised version of the edition published five years ago. The author states that distance education emerged, for the last 20 years, from an individual pursuit to a learning supported by different medium.So, among other subjects, the author reflects on the disruptive effect of de Net on distance education. T. Anderson also explains the advantages of provinding the book open access free.
This book is neither academic on distance education nor a "guide" on this matter.
From the same author, you can see here another book intittled "E-learning in the 21st century: a framework of research and practice".
From J. Stephenson, the book " Teaching & Learning online: pedegogies for new tecnologies" provides de reader a general idea on online methods&tecnologies, from several authors around the world.
Interesting article from T, Anderson.
It can be read here.
It starts presenting self- paced learning and presenting also several exemples of sel-paced learning, giving also a brief aproach on avantages and limitations on this alternative learning method. Interesting for beginners, since is easy to read.
Another interesting article on self-paced learning from Jason F. Rhode, intitled "Interaction Equivalency in Self-Paced Online Learning Environments: An Exploration of Learner Preferences" from the International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning,Volume 10, Number 1,February – 2009.
Abstract:This study demonstrated that depending on the specific circumstance, not all forms of interaction may be either equally valued by learners or effective. Participants differentiated among the various learning interactions available and indicated that informal interactions were as important as formal interactions in determining the quality of the online learning experience. Participants also reported the activity of blogging as being equally valued and in some ways superior to instructor-directed asynchronous discussion via the discussion board in a learning management system.
An importante book from Terry Anderson is "Theory and Practice of Online Learning"
You can check a glimpse of the book here.
This is a revised version of the edition published five years ago. The author states that distance education emerged, for the last 20 years, from an individual pursuit to a learning supported by different medium.So, among other subjects, the author reflects on the disruptive effect of de Net on distance education. T. Anderson also explains the advantages of provinding the book open access free.
This book is neither academic on distance education nor a "guide" on this matter.
From the same author, you can see here another book intittled "E-learning in the 21st century: a framework of research and practice".
From J. Stephenson, the book " Teaching & Learning online: pedegogies for new tecnologies" provides de reader a general idea on online methods&tecnologies, from several authors around the world.
Interesting article from T, Anderson.
Self-paced learning
Definition- Teach-yourself method of learning that is initiated and directed by the learner.It's a learning method that provide a convenient alternative to the traditional classroom:
Reading a book to acquire new information about a topic.
Reading a book, listening to accompanying audiotapes and completing exercises in a workbook.
Reading a reference manual and watching a video.
Completing a computer-assisted learning (CAL) course that uses interactive computer modules for knowledge transfer and one-on-one work with the clinical trainer for skills transfer, first with models and then with clients.
It has several advantages:
Learners can learn information and skills when they need them.
Learners are not as dependent on the structure and pace established by the trainer.
Assuming control of the learning process is highly motivating for many learners.
Each learner has the same level of participation in the learning process. Participants are active rather than passive, and assume greater responsibility for their own learning.
Because most self-paced learning courses allow participants to begin and end a segment of the training course at any time, it is an efficient use of training time and resources.
Learning activities can be organized sequentially.
But is not a benefit for all:
Most participants have not learned this way before, so they may feel uncomfortable with learning on their own.
Participants may lack the necessary motivation to work independently.
Participants may have poor reading skills, especially when the language of the reference materials is different from their primary language. Because most self-paced learning approaches require reading, this can be a major limitation.
Participants may possess poor time management skills. Procrastination may make the self-paced learning process less effective than it can be.
Most trainers did not learn this way and therefore need training to become effective facilitators of self-paced learning.
Trainers may feel that they do not have time to manage a self-paced learning system.
It may be challenging and time-consuming to design and develop the appropriate learning materials, in either print or electronic format.
Reading a book to acquire new information about a topic.
Reading a book, listening to accompanying audiotapes and completing exercises in a workbook.
Reading a reference manual and watching a video.
Completing a computer-assisted learning (CAL) course that uses interactive computer modules for knowledge transfer and one-on-one work with the clinical trainer for skills transfer, first with models and then with clients.
It has several advantages:
Learners can learn information and skills when they need them.
Learners are not as dependent on the structure and pace established by the trainer.
Assuming control of the learning process is highly motivating for many learners.
Each learner has the same level of participation in the learning process. Participants are active rather than passive, and assume greater responsibility for their own learning.
Because most self-paced learning courses allow participants to begin and end a segment of the training course at any time, it is an efficient use of training time and resources.
Learning activities can be organized sequentially.
But is not a benefit for all:
Most participants have not learned this way before, so they may feel uncomfortable with learning on their own.
Participants may lack the necessary motivation to work independently.
Participants may have poor reading skills, especially when the language of the reference materials is different from their primary language. Because most self-paced learning approaches require reading, this can be a major limitation.
Participants may possess poor time management skills. Procrastination may make the self-paced learning process less effective than it can be.
Most trainers did not learn this way and therefore need training to become effective facilitators of self-paced learning.
Trainers may feel that they do not have time to manage a self-paced learning system.
It may be challenging and time-consuming to design and develop the appropriate learning materials, in either print or electronic format.
sexta-feira, 6 de novembro de 2009
Review on learning objects
1. Learning Object: by Helena Prieto - http://toonlet.com/archive?m=s&i=35296
2. Learning Object: by Mónica Velosa - http://toonlet.com/archive?m=s&i=34887
Both authors choose toonlet to present a theory: cooperative freedom.
Helena’s toonlet presents some aspects on cooperative learning: it starts to emphasize that no one can do anything alone. This way, individual freedom and cooperation are combined with an explanation that refers the importance of dividing tasks, as most works of this class point out. This work also states that “sharing knowledge improves the quality of work and learning gains.”
Mónica choose a different way to emphasize some points on cooperative learning. After a dialogue with a friend, Sandra, the author starts to explain the Hexagon of cooperative freedom, synthesizing that it combines individual freedom with meaningful freedom. Then, prof. Morten talks about several theories of distance education – authors like Moore, Peters, Holmberg are reminded –, to end referring that freedom is as important as cooperation, for Distance Education student. Prof. Morten also says that Cooperative Freedom has six points: time, space, rhythm, media, access and curriculum.
With a very informal tool, the theory of Cooperative Freedom is presented by the authors, Mónica and Helena, pointing out some essential ideas.
I think that, since toonlet is a very synthetic way of communication, only some aspects of the theories are mentioned. Though both works refer the same theory, these toonlets present a different approach; the first one imagine a possible conversation between students to emphasize how collaboration is important to students. In addition, one can also state that this work points out that community members must be urged and stimulated to contribute to the community and benefit from it. The second work chooses another approach, mentioning authors that systematized fundamental ideas on distance education and then explaining six points of freedom.
When I choose these two learning objects, I did it because I found out that this tool is very interesting. The students that present theory of Cooperative Freedom do it explaining important aspects of this learning theory. I also chose these works because they emphasize different views, on cooperative freedom. Both learning object present cooperative learning in a very clear and concise way, meeting the purpose of this unit, activity 3, and I enjoyed reading both.
Congratulations to Mónica and Helena for your work
2. Learning Object: by Mónica Velosa - http://toonlet.com/archive?m=s&i=34887
Both authors choose toonlet to present a theory: cooperative freedom.
Helena’s toonlet presents some aspects on cooperative learning: it starts to emphasize that no one can do anything alone. This way, individual freedom and cooperation are combined with an explanation that refers the importance of dividing tasks, as most works of this class point out. This work also states that “sharing knowledge improves the quality of work and learning gains.”
Mónica choose a different way to emphasize some points on cooperative learning. After a dialogue with a friend, Sandra, the author starts to explain the Hexagon of cooperative freedom, synthesizing that it combines individual freedom with meaningful freedom. Then, prof. Morten talks about several theories of distance education – authors like Moore, Peters, Holmberg are reminded –, to end referring that freedom is as important as cooperation, for Distance Education student. Prof. Morten also says that Cooperative Freedom has six points: time, space, rhythm, media, access and curriculum.
With a very informal tool, the theory of Cooperative Freedom is presented by the authors, Mónica and Helena, pointing out some essential ideas.
I think that, since toonlet is a very synthetic way of communication, only some aspects of the theories are mentioned. Though both works refer the same theory, these toonlets present a different approach; the first one imagine a possible conversation between students to emphasize how collaboration is important to students. In addition, one can also state that this work points out that community members must be urged and stimulated to contribute to the community and benefit from it. The second work chooses another approach, mentioning authors that systematized fundamental ideas on distance education and then explaining six points of freedom.
When I choose these two learning objects, I did it because I found out that this tool is very interesting. The students that present theory of Cooperative Freedom do it explaining important aspects of this learning theory. I also chose these works because they emphasize different views, on cooperative freedom. Both learning object present cooperative learning in a very clear and concise way, meeting the purpose of this unit, activity 3, and I enjoyed reading both.
Congratulations to Mónica and Helena for your work
sábado, 31 de outubro de 2009
Cooperative Learning & Transparency
Hi everyone:
My collegue Marco and I made this "Learning Object" as required by prof. Morten.
It's about cooperative learning, the advantages of this learning theory, emphasizing how important tranparency can be. Students should be stimulated to be visible as potential partners and resources for others. This way, transparency could be a huge cooperative resource, because people’s cooperation is supported on the knowledge about each other and on having access to some common information.
Hope you'll enjoy as much as we did.
Cooperative Learning & Transparency
My collegue Marco and I made this "Learning Object" as required by prof. Morten.
It's about cooperative learning, the advantages of this learning theory, emphasizing how important tranparency can be. Students should be stimulated to be visible as potential partners and resources for others. This way, transparency could be a huge cooperative resource, because people’s cooperation is supported on the knowledge about each other and on having access to some common information.
Hope you'll enjoy as much as we did.
Cooperative Learning & Transparency
Etiquetas:
cooperative learning,
mpel03,
PPEL,
transparency
A qualidade dos cursos online

Terminámos a tradução de dois textos, originalmente em inglês, sobre a qualidade dos cursos online e da sua avaliação.
Após a elaboração da tradução, segue-se uma fase de debate, no fórum, dos temas propostos.
Esta actividade avivou-me a memória, fazendo-me recuar ao momento inicial do Mestrado, recordando a identificação de um conjunto de cartacterísticas imprescindíveis ao estudante de cursos online:
- ter capacidade para partilhar a sua experiência, as suas dúvidas, mostrando abertura para as questões levantadas pelos colegas e experiências vividas pelos outros;
- capacidade de comunicar através da escrita; o estudante deve capaz de expor as suas próprias dúvidas;
- capacidade de reflexão e ponderação, assim como de aceitação das críticas construtivas;
- ser autodisciplinadao e estar auto-motivado para se comprometer,diariamente, com as actividades do curso online ;
- possuir e-skills necessárias ao curso online que frequenta;
- ter a percepção de que o curso online frequentado promove aprendizagens de grabde qualidade/valor.
Para esta unidade, utilizámos os seguintes recursos:
PENNA, Maria Pietronilla & STARA, Vera (2008) "Approaches to E-learning quality Assessment". http://isdm.univ-tln.fr/PDF/isdm32/isdm_pietronilla.pdf
WISENBERG, Faye & STACEY, Elizabeth (2005) "Reflections on teaching and Learning Online:Quality program design, delivery and support issues from a cross-global perspective". Distance Education Vol.26, Nº3, (385-404). http://casat.unr.edu/docs/Weisenberg2005.pdf
sexta-feira, 30 de outubro de 2009
Annotated Bibliography
With this post I aim to present an annotated bibliography for PPEL. This is a enrolment of some of the most interesting papers or essential articles that I read.
I also leave the links to online papers and a summary of each one, as well as a brief personal opinion on the article refered.
ARTICLE - Um Modelo conceitual para Aprendizagem
Colaborativa Baseada na execução de Projetos pela Web
AUTORES - Luisa Aleyda García González e Wilson Vicente Ruggiero (2008)
You can read this article here.
ABSTRACT - LMS systems today provide a network environment
to support interaction in a collaborative learning space.
However, there are few that explore how to design the group
instruction, and how to execute collaborative activities and how
to control the group interaction. This work has considered the
diverse group learning basic elements that support the success of
the group learning activities. Moreover, this work has integrated
and enhanced the procedure steps that support the creation and
execution of the project-based collaborative learning activities.
This paper describes these elements and procedures through a
conceptual model (MAC-BP).
Index Terms—Collaborative learning, E-learning, Learning
objects, Project-based learning.
This paper presents a guidelines
to users of distance education. It is also very usefull to teatchers when they need to use tecnologies.On the other hand, resources involving specific learning activities Web 2.0 and lack of studies on the theme of use educational objects and new applications are a motivation to read and produce thesis in the área.
This articles provides a guide for teachers when using collaborative and electronic learning based on the method of group projects, supported on a constructive perspective, organizing learning objects
involved in the process of collaboration with the purpose of being reusable.
ARTICLE - E-learning 2.0: new frontier for student empowerment
AUTORES - William Renner (2009)
You can read this article here.
This a paper that relates tradicional elearning to elearning 2.0. This article identifies essencial themes emerging on recent literature, relating these themes to individual, social and scholarly empowerment. This paper has a social constructivist perspective, applied to technology and learning in academy students.
ARTICLE - Computer-mediated communication in the undergraduate writing classroom: A study of the relationship of online discourse and classroom discourse in two writing classes
AUTHOR - Robert P. Yagelsky & Jeffrey T. Grabill (2002)
You can read this paper here.
ABSTRACT - This article examines the relationship between electronic discourse and face-to-face discourse in two undergraduate university writing classes in which computer-mediated communication (CMC) was employed to supplement regular in-class lecture and discussion. The study explores the potential influence of in-class discourse on the nature and rates of student participation in online discussions(...)
I found this article very intersting since i've doing some reading on use of tecnologies in online environments. I thinks that another important aspect os this paper is the comparison between online classes and face-to-face classes. It also points out the way that the tutor manages the uses of CMC technologies, the way he defines the structure of the course and students's perceptions of the importance of CMC technologies when learning. This study suggests that students' uses of CMC technologies is related also to their status as students envolved in a university course.
I've also found a paper, in portuguese, about the Theory of Cooperative Freedom , and other learning theories, that can be read here and a tranlation from Laurinda Leite of an article of Prof. Paulsen that you can read here.
I also leave the links to online papers and a summary of each one, as well as a brief personal opinion on the article refered.
ARTICLE - Um Modelo conceitual para Aprendizagem
Colaborativa Baseada na execução de Projetos pela Web
AUTORES - Luisa Aleyda García González e Wilson Vicente Ruggiero (2008)
You can read this article here.
ABSTRACT - LMS systems today provide a network environment
to support interaction in a collaborative learning space.
However, there are few that explore how to design the group
instruction, and how to execute collaborative activities and how
to control the group interaction. This work has considered the
diverse group learning basic elements that support the success of
the group learning activities. Moreover, this work has integrated
and enhanced the procedure steps that support the creation and
execution of the project-based collaborative learning activities.
This paper describes these elements and procedures through a
conceptual model (MAC-BP).
Index Terms—Collaborative learning, E-learning, Learning
objects, Project-based learning.
This paper presents a guidelines
to users of distance education. It is also very usefull to teatchers when they need to use tecnologies.On the other hand, resources involving specific learning activities Web 2.0 and lack of studies on the theme of use educational objects and new applications are a motivation to read and produce thesis in the área.
This articles provides a guide for teachers when using collaborative and electronic learning based on the method of group projects, supported on a constructive perspective, organizing learning objects
involved in the process of collaboration with the purpose of being reusable.
ARTICLE - E-learning 2.0: new frontier for student empowerment
AUTORES - William Renner (2009)
You can read this article here.
This a paper that relates tradicional elearning to elearning 2.0. This article identifies essencial themes emerging on recent literature, relating these themes to individual, social and scholarly empowerment. This paper has a social constructivist perspective, applied to technology and learning in academy students.
ARTICLE - Computer-mediated communication in the undergraduate writing classroom: A study of the relationship of online discourse and classroom discourse in two writing classes
AUTHOR - Robert P. Yagelsky & Jeffrey T. Grabill (2002)
You can read this paper here.
ABSTRACT - This article examines the relationship between electronic discourse and face-to-face discourse in two undergraduate university writing classes in which computer-mediated communication (CMC) was employed to supplement regular in-class lecture and discussion. The study explores the potential influence of in-class discourse on the nature and rates of student participation in online discussions(...)
I found this article very intersting since i've doing some reading on use of tecnologies in online environments. I thinks that another important aspect os this paper is the comparison between online classes and face-to-face classes. It also points out the way that the tutor manages the uses of CMC technologies, the way he defines the structure of the course and students's perceptions of the importance of CMC technologies when learning. This study suggests that students' uses of CMC technologies is related also to their status as students envolved in a university course.
I've also found a paper, in portuguese, about the Theory of Cooperative Freedom , and other learning theories, that can be read here and a tranlation from Laurinda Leite of an article of Prof. Paulsen that you can read here.
Subscrever:
Mensagens (Atom)
